
I am sure that I’m not alone in my view that the current Cricket commentators on Sky Sports are simply not good enough. They have a silver lining for every mistake, blunder, error and they are too afraid to say anything bad about the currently under performing England side. Now, there was one man that stood out from the crowd of ’every cloud ..’ commentators and that man was the legendary Geoffrey Boycott OBE.
Boycott is most well known for his ’controversial’ England career as an opening batsman. He would bat for days on end, accumulating large scores but at a snails pace. This caused problems between him and his team mates, especially all-rounder Ian Botham and legendary fast bowler Fred Trueman. British sports journalist Ian Wooldridge OBE once said “Boycott, in short, walks alone". Whilst many disagreed with Boycotts ‘selfish’ batting style, he did play 108 tests for England and scored over 8,000 test runs, so its not like he didn’t do his bit for the team.
They say that ‘those who cant do talk about it’ and that’s exactly what he did. After retiring at the age of 42 with an average of 47 runs per game underneath his belt he moved on to commentary. He was just as influential within cricket whilst in the commentary box, he invented the phrase ‘corridor of uncertainty’ which is the most well known phrase through out cricket to this day. It is also believed that he invented the ‘key test’, this is where you use a car key or a house key, stick it into the cricket pitch and you can tell how hard the wicket is.
His first job in the media was with Talk Sport who offered said that they would stick by him despite his assault conviction which was upheld on appeal. He continued to commentate for the sports based radio station, along with several satellite and Asian channels. His commentary career was sky rocketing, until his life was threatened by throat cancer, it seemed that if he did beat the cancer it would be unlikely that he would ever commentate again. However, having successfully undergone chemotherapy he was back in our ears by late 2003. That is when he hit the big time and struck a deal with channel 4 commentating on the 2005 Ashes victory. That is when we all sat up and took notice of the greatest living Yorkshire man again.
The 2005 Ashes was one of the greatest performances I have ever seen by a team, in any sport, but it wasn’t flawless and you could bet your money on Boycott picking up on those flaws. He would tell it how it was, he didn’t care if it made England look bad, all he cared about was his opinion and getting that opinion across to the public. Obviously many people were not happy with his honest criticism of the England team, especially the players, after witnessing a dropped catch he said ’ I reckon my mum could have caught that in her pinny’. This didn’t make him popular within the England camp, Steve Harmison once said ‘The fact is that within the England dressing room Boycott's views are regarded as a joke…. Indeed, quite a few of us cringe whenever he comes near’. Harmison should just be pleased that Boycott wasn’t commentating on his first ball in England’s defence of the Ashes in 2006 when he managed to bowl it to Andrew Flintoff at first slip!
Geoffrey Boycott’s absence in that Ashes series was extremely noticeable as England lost 5-0 and there wasn’t a commentator there who would say what every England fan was thinking, “England are playing crap!”. I am quite sure that if Boycott had been commentating on that series he would have used a lot harsher language than that, and I don’t think anyone could have argued with him. The reason that Boycott was absent for that, shocking England performance was that Sky Sports had just bought the rights to show all live International Cricket and they didn’t see Geoffrey Boycott as a suitable commentator for there new brand of cricket.
Instead they replaced him with the likes of Michael Holding, a West Indian who has never played for England, Nick Knight, who only ever played 17 tests for England and made his name in county cricket, and Ian Botham who in my opinion shouldn’t be in the commentary box, he should be coaching this below par England team.
So Sky Sports have replaced an outspoken, honest, truthful, England legend with a group of ‘yes’ men who would describe a wide ball as innovative bowling. When will Sky Sports realise that we want honest commentary, we want someone to tell it as it is, we want the greatest living Yorkshire man Geoffrey Boycott.